Thursday 16 August 2012

Geography for Civils

It has been quite a long time since I wrote my last blog here... the worst part is that I committed in my previous post that I would be writing about civils preparations in the subsequent posts, but I didn't.. So first of all, I beg apology from everybody- particularly from ppl who asked me regarding Geography optional preparation and I told them every time that I'll be writing soon... For last one month I had been travelling for various reasons, so I coudn't write... I am sorry for that...

           Now the prelims result is out, service allocation is done and everything is set for next mains... So I find it obligatory on part of me to write at least now before I forget the jargon of geography and Pubad and everything...

           This time around after the disclosure of marks of CSE2011, it has been observed that Pub.ad, Geography and Sociology particularly have been at the receiving end of UPSC... people who scored 350s in pubad and geography in their previous attempts have been reduced to 280s-290s... So a drop in average score is quite evident.. Some how or other I managed to score 376(201+175) in geography... So I feel like sharing my preparation strategy for geography here...

           To be frank enough, in this attempt I devoted most of my time towards Pubad preparation as I was not confident in it.. After PT results, all of a sudden I realised that Geography is almost untouched... It was almost a panic situation... I still laugh remembering about that time when I was sweating inside my a/c room.. I settled down in few days and revised the entire Neetu madam's(direction) notes in 12-14 days straight...
That gave me a sigh of relief... but the thing to be noted is that I had Geography as my 1st optional in both my previous PT attempts...So I had already read the standard books several times... so the cummulative effort had worked...

          Now lets approach the papers systematically

Paper1:-

               1. Coverage of syllabus- The structure of the paper has changed over the time.. now UPSC is no more asking 60 markers.. so the demand is that the candidate is required to cover the entire syllabus.. short notes have become compulsory too. So it is always advisable to know sumthing about everything rather than everything about something.... If somebody knows 2/3 points about a topic, it is good enough to write a 12 marker short note... So dont leave any chapter or topic.. atleast have some basic knowhow about all the subtopics written in the syllabus...

               2. Time management-  the major challenge is completion of paper.. this year as many as 16 questions were to be answered in 3 hrs which is a bit challenging... completion of paper shoud be given priority, at the same time standard of answer has to be maintained... I followed the formula of writing 2 full questions in first 1 1/2 hrs and 3 full questions in next... so initial 2 questions were well written which carried a good impression I suppose...

               3. Diagrams- draw as many diagrams as u can but don't draw redundant ones as it kills tym at the same time carries bad impression.. I had drawn around 35-40 diagrams in paper1... I drew diagrams in black gel pen with free hand in most of the cases there by saving time at the same time it was complimenting well to the blue gel written text... eye appeal works... so give emphasis to that...

               4. Length of answer- UPSC prescribes definite word limit for every answer... but its my own experience that its not a crime if u cross it... So it is up to you to manage time and space... try to write more than others... always start an answer from a fresh page...

Paper2:-

              1. Mapping- This the trickiest one to handle in geography optional.. previously it was an asset when UPSC used to ask to locate entries like Hirakud dam and Cauvery river... now they r asking almost anything.. but if one observes carefully, entire mapping question can be divided into 2 parts- static and current entries... they are equally distributed also... for example if 12 entries are asked then 6 has to be from static Indian geography and 6 from contemporary relevance.... candidate with above average geography knowledge can easily answer 4/5 out of 6 static entries.. So knowing 2/3 contemporary entries is good enough... my point is that its not advisable to go after contemporary entries as one cannot actually trace UPSC and time consumed in that process will be too much.. So read the static entries thoroughly from any source and for contemporary entries make your individual compilation from newspaper reading and all that entries that are available in the market of various institutes... I would request candidates not to get emotional with mapping and devote much time on it...

              2. India map and diagrams- minimum one India map has to be drawn for every paper2 answer.. Draw it neatly with 3/4th of page with proper bordering and indexing. Pick up diagrams from Khullar book- particularly unit 3 has very good diagrams...

             3. examples and case studies- these things are always appreciated... Newspapers and magazines like yojna and 'Geography and You' carry good case studies... anticipate the questions and prepare some examples with data for them... for example last year, 'civil aviation industry' and 'pharmaceutical industry' were in news and UPSC asked questions from that.. So be very vigilant while reading newspaper..

Books and references:-


  • Physical Geography - Savindra Singh
  • Human Geography - Majid Hussain
  • Models and Theories - Majid Hussain( this book has good compilation of diagrams)
  • Indian Geography - Khullar( unit 1 has to be thoroughly read.. unit 2 can be avoided.. unit3 is good, some chapters like water resourses, multipurpose projects can be read)
  • Dictionary by K Sidhartha
  • Any institute's notes can be supplemented for timely revision...


Queries are welcome... I'll try to address to the best of my abilities...

         

           

         



41 comments:

  1. Thanks Sir, for valuable info for the aspirants....

    ReplyDelete
  2. sir, starting with NCERT is good enough to gain the basics???

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. NCERTs are good for basic preliminary reading.. but from optionals point of view u sud start reading standard txt books as early as possible after finishing the NCERTs

      Delete
  3. thanks for guiding us. would you mind giving us some guidance for pub.ad....

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I'll try to write one on Public administration...

      Delete
  4. Sir,
    First of all congratulation a lot for the success and I strongly believe you will taste a lot of success in future.
    I have an unusual question regarding using Gel pen in exam.
    By the statement
    "I drew diagrams in black gel pen with free hand in most of the cases there by saving time at the same time it was complimenting well to the blue gel written text... eye appeal works... so give emphasis to that..."
    Does it mean that I can write answer(and not only diagram) using GEL pen or is it only for the diagram(I am little bit confused regarding using GEL Pen).
    Once again thank you so much for the effort.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks a lot for your good wishes...

      I wrote my entire exam(CSE 2011) with blue gel pen and drew the diagrams in black gel... I hope I made it clear...

      Its your decision to write in gel or ball pen... UPSC has nowhere given guidelines regarding this...

      Delete
  5. sir please tell if its alright to choose pubad or it will go more off the edge in times to come.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Pubad is a good optional.. In future it will probably find more space than any other optional in the syllabus in changed pattern of examination

      Delete
  6. Sir regarding reference books u referred only those books u mentioned + neetu mams notes or other books also.
    Please tell how u managed back to back papers of pub ad and geography in mains.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. For pubad u'll b getting 1 and half day of gap... but for Geography it will be a problem.. so
      1. be mentally tough
      2. prepare the syllabus of geography thoroughly
      3. revice paper1 as much as u can the day before... dont bother fro paper 2
      4. utilise the gap betwen papers and revise Neetu madam's 2nd paper notes(if ur redaing that note) ,and finish the physical aspects atleast
      5. u sud hav one readymade compilatioon of mapping... do revise that in that gap.

      Delete
    2. Thank you so much for this thorough guidance its perfect but sir u didn't said anything about the sources of reference i am referring neetu mams entire class material plus the books that u mentioned but is anything else needed like book for specified topic as D S lal for climatology.
      thanks in advance once again..

      Delete
    3. DS Lal not required... As I have already told specialisation in a particular topic is no more required rather broad coverage helps...

      Delete
  7. Hello Sir,
    Thanks for you guidance... Can you please share your strategy for map pointing along with the list of places that you practised.

    ReplyDelete
  8. Hello...

    For static map pointing U read frm 1 source- may b any coaching material... for contemporary entries, notedown frm newspapers- the places which r in news... in savindra Singh books particularly in geomorphology chapter thr r some examples frm india... read that...
    Hope it helps

    ReplyDelete
  9. Thank you so much Sir for the prompt reply!!

    ReplyDelete
  10. Hello Anupam Bhai,

    I am from Odisha and preparing for CSE-2013.I have completed my Engineering in EEE. I have decided to take PUB AD as one optional paper, but very much confused on my second option. The confusion is between SOCIOLOGY and GEOGRAPHY. please Guide me how I can select my second optional, After reading your blog, I feel confident for geography and was good at geography during my schooling. please suggest,what it is required to take geography for my optional.

    please Bhai, waiting for ur reply........

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. if u have interest in geography, take it up...

      Delete
  11. Hi Anupam,

    Thanks a lot.This will really help.Sorry for sounding ignorant but who's Neetu Mam and where can I get her notes?
    Also will be really great if u can post a similar blog on public ad coz ppl who dnt hav access to coaching classes will be benefited.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. neetu maam's institute is in karol bagh- new delhi... u can find her notes in old rajinder nagar market...

      Delete
  12. Sir,

    Congrats,I have given mains 2012 and waiting for results, however I could not present my answers in a good manner probably because of lack of memorizing and answer writing, I am planning to make short notes for topics for quick revision, can you suggest my how to make them and from what sources.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. sorry for replying late... I wud suggest u to get readymade notes from any insitute by either attending classes or xerox... writing own notes kills time...

      Delete
  13. Sir, I passed out from college in 2012.I had studied Indian geography in my college days.But after that I couldn't touch geography much..I would be giving prelims this year.My second optional in Pub Ad where my prepartion is going prety well.Sir could you tell me if I would be having sufficient time after the prelims examination..I mean there would be GS preparationa also.SO will it be ok to take geography or I should start exploting for other optionals.
    Hoping to hear form you very soon

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. geography is always a good optional for civils...

      Delete
  14. Sir,
    In your opinion, is neetu Mam's classes worth joining? I have already done a coaching but I need to hone my concepts.
    Or her notes are self explanatory?

    Does she take interest in answer writing skills too?
    How are the map classes she takes?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. 1. I joined neetu mam and it was helpful
      2. u can get the notes and read it for revision.
      3. notes are not that self explanatory; biggest benifit is that revision becomes easy..
      4. she takes interest in answer writing skills if u show ur answers to her
      4. map classes are good... better than many institutes...

      Delete
  15. sir ,
    preparing notes for geography is necessary or time wate . or else have to depend on the text books . can u please suggest me with that . i was bit confusing

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. read text books... get notes of nay good institute by attending classes or xerox as it will be useful for revision... preparing own notes is time consuming...

      Delete
  16. how should one go for geography ..i am reading 11 and 12 so after that what to do tell me for prelims and mains point of view...optional geography and if u know geography coching when to take and from whom reply asap!! thankuing u sir

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I took coaching at Neetu maám... I dont hav exact idea about other institutes... please read the standard text books mentioned by me in the blog...

      Delete
  17. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  18. i was planing to take coaching after finshing my self studies of geography..is it necessary to take for other subjects even if thy are not our optional as i beleive one can prepare with jugad also. for history i have started with 11 and 12 india focusing first so i need to make notes at first reading or how to make notes from it.last thing is when i should take coaching..in view of prelims and mains both..

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. waiting for your reply and geography i havent read for so long in school as i ma science pass out but i have always find geography likeable then other so ,taking your view also anyone new to it can do for civils or not

      Delete
    2. This comment has been removed by the author.

      Delete
    3. U sud take coaching a year bfore writing exam i.e. for example if u r planning to write 2015 prelims then start from 2014 may/june... and geography is equally good for everybody and definitely helpful for science graduates...

      Delete
    4. agreed sir,so before taking any for prelims i should or must complete my self studies as directly going to coaching would be sensible decision ?

      Delete
  19. also sir coaching should be taken for pre and mains together or first prelims and after clearing pre then mains coaching ?

    ReplyDelete
  20. Sir, Can You plz help me out? How should I approach to answer the following Q.

    Q- "The physiographic regions of India can be identified on the basis of its geo-structures." Give a schematic suggestion of such regions and mention the geo-structural basis of each of the regions. (15+10=25)

    I am confused with the phrase "schematic suggestion".

    ReplyDelete
  21. Sir please tell me how to complete savinder Singh book of physical geography.At first look book is looking too much bulky and fact based. Then what to do? Prepare all chapters from 1 to last or any trick? How to complete this book? With preparing notes or not?

    ReplyDelete
  22. Sir please tell me how to complete savinder Singh book of physical geography.At first look book is looking too much bulky and fact based. Then what to do? Prepare all chapters from 1 to last or any trick? How to complete this book? With preparing notes or not?

    ReplyDelete